“Slop” is subjectively defined, and yet shares certain universal features: it is always seen as negative, and connotes mass distribution to an ignorant group of consumers.
I’ve been reading a lot about communication as ritual vs communication for the purpose of sharing ideas, and particularly the notion that people who don’t enjoy small talk don’t place a high value on conversation-as-ritual, at least as compared with conversation-as-idea-exchange. It seems to me like there’s a parallel with high content/low form (idea exchange) vs low content/high form (small talk/ritual communication, slop), except maybe that ritual communication has a positive connotation for some of the participants and a pro-social purpose (connecting humans in community). Does that track?
That’s so interesting. I personally dislike small talk, and this has changed my perspective on it. Do you mind providing resources that talk about these ideas? So cool!
I don’t have a specific resource off the top of my head, but particularly in autistic and neurodiverse spaces not liking small talk is very common, and there’s a lot of explainers the last few years like “did you know if your neurotypical friend is talking to you they might not be trying to communicate actual information, and simply like talking to you?” Which I think I connected to a “ritual purpose” of conversation through linguistics creators like Aleksic and others. I’ve also seen a lot of therapeutic talk about the importance of feeling heard and understood, regardless of neurotype. We _like_ to feel like someone is listening and getting what we’re putting out there. And sometimes when we don’t have specific information to convey, we still want that feeling. (Honestly I might even liken the impulse to stimming, because it’s an attempt to arrive at a particular feeling without the substance usually associated with the action. I lack the bona fides to back that up - it just strikes me that way.)
The thing that makes small talk feel important to me, then, even though I’m not particularly interested in it on its face, is that it’s a way of seeing other people and recognizing a need they have. I might not share that need in particular, but how can I expect to have my needs met if I’m not willing to meet the needs of others? It’s a way of showing care, even if it doesn’t mean that to me.
I think there’s another function of small talk - when we’re talking about the stuff of everyday life, part of what we’re doing is confirming that we’re on the same page. My mom called the other day and asked me about the price of eggs, because it felt weird to her that it got so high and then fell so fast. She didn’t say it aloud, but she wanted me to answer the unspoken question, “it’s weird, right?” We’re aligning our sense of how things work, and that’s valuable in its own way. (We also wound up talking about some of the drivers of egg prices over the last couple years, because if I know information it’s probably going to show up, even in a small talk context. I can’t not. 😆)
Anyway, I hope that’s something you were looking for? If you’d like to chat toss me a DM, I’m happy to go deep on the topic. 😊
this is making me think of disruptive innovation which is like a social innovation concept where a firm releases cheaper and simpler products (seen as worse, could be slop) that can be used by a larger number of people more conveniently. like developing minute clinics, which can quickly expand less specialized healthcare into communities vs hospitals which are more advanced but also expensive and harder to establish. similarly everyone can access and understand brainrot, can everyone access and understand fine art? maybe they can but it's a good question. theoretically, disruptive innovation can increase investment/create markets in new industries so maybe we see slop increase in prominence in the future. or slop becomes too advanced and requires too much subtext to understand and create and it loses its disruptive nature.
but idk i find it interesting that we quickly recognize slop as inherently negative but generally people don't treat slop applied to real world contexts as harshly
From an online cat researcher's perspective, it is interesting to see that AI-generated cat videos are among the first slop created for maximum engagement. Cats drive engagement. Just to be fair, not all cat videos are slop.
Defining "content" as "preservation of human intentionality" seems, at the very least, highly inaccurate. The bulleted posts you see on LinkedIn, articles about making money, TikToks of attractive people performing a trend - these are content. Meanwhile, personal essays and short stories in lit-fic, and the moving pictures that Martin Scorsese would consider to be "films" - these are NOT content. But they most definitely preserve human intentionality.
you're confusing "content" in the art criticism sense with "content" in the commercial sense (which I have written about before). these are different things entirely
In no. 7 I think "intellectual" can also refer to emotional and nostalgic valences; it's helpful to have your insights here on how to distinguish one's own content from slop. I got a copy of Algospeak BTW but it was shelved in "philosophy" at the large chain bookstore near me, so if fellow readers here are interested in Adam's book, ask a sales clerk to help you find it.
I’m a little confused by the graph: is everything on the graph what is considered slop, or just the dotted line? I wouldn’t think of Starry Night as slop unless it’s there because of its popularity and endless replications that have become cliche (so why that painting and not, say, Mona Lisa?) Was Van Gogh painting for ‘engagement’ as implied here, or the closest to some kind of virality in his time?
"engagement" only matters for social media. This graph is about how "slop" relies on a subjective distinction between form and content. Starry Night has high form, in that it's very successful in its particular medium (being a painting)
Slop is not form. Even the example on offer, "food, not a type of food" illustrates that. "A type of food" indicates a degree of form, distinguishable from other types.
I’ve been reading a lot about communication as ritual vs communication for the purpose of sharing ideas, and particularly the notion that people who don’t enjoy small talk don’t place a high value on conversation-as-ritual, at least as compared with conversation-as-idea-exchange. It seems to me like there’s a parallel with high content/low form (idea exchange) vs low content/high form (small talk/ritual communication, slop), except maybe that ritual communication has a positive connotation for some of the participants and a pro-social purpose (connecting humans in community). Does that track?
yes, beautifully expressed :)
That’s so interesting. I personally dislike small talk, and this has changed my perspective on it. Do you mind providing resources that talk about these ideas? So cool!
I don’t have a specific resource off the top of my head, but particularly in autistic and neurodiverse spaces not liking small talk is very common, and there’s a lot of explainers the last few years like “did you know if your neurotypical friend is talking to you they might not be trying to communicate actual information, and simply like talking to you?” Which I think I connected to a “ritual purpose” of conversation through linguistics creators like Aleksic and others. I’ve also seen a lot of therapeutic talk about the importance of feeling heard and understood, regardless of neurotype. We _like_ to feel like someone is listening and getting what we’re putting out there. And sometimes when we don’t have specific information to convey, we still want that feeling. (Honestly I might even liken the impulse to stimming, because it’s an attempt to arrive at a particular feeling without the substance usually associated with the action. I lack the bona fides to back that up - it just strikes me that way.)
The thing that makes small talk feel important to me, then, even though I’m not particularly interested in it on its face, is that it’s a way of seeing other people and recognizing a need they have. I might not share that need in particular, but how can I expect to have my needs met if I’m not willing to meet the needs of others? It’s a way of showing care, even if it doesn’t mean that to me.
I think there’s another function of small talk - when we’re talking about the stuff of everyday life, part of what we’re doing is confirming that we’re on the same page. My mom called the other day and asked me about the price of eggs, because it felt weird to her that it got so high and then fell so fast. She didn’t say it aloud, but she wanted me to answer the unspoken question, “it’s weird, right?” We’re aligning our sense of how things work, and that’s valuable in its own way. (We also wound up talking about some of the drivers of egg prices over the last couple years, because if I know information it’s probably going to show up, even in a small talk context. I can’t not. 😆)
Anyway, I hope that’s something you were looking for? If you’d like to chat toss me a DM, I’m happy to go deep on the topic. 😊
this is making me think of disruptive innovation which is like a social innovation concept where a firm releases cheaper and simpler products (seen as worse, could be slop) that can be used by a larger number of people more conveniently. like developing minute clinics, which can quickly expand less specialized healthcare into communities vs hospitals which are more advanced but also expensive and harder to establish. similarly everyone can access and understand brainrot, can everyone access and understand fine art? maybe they can but it's a good question. theoretically, disruptive innovation can increase investment/create markets in new industries so maybe we see slop increase in prominence in the future. or slop becomes too advanced and requires too much subtext to understand and create and it loses its disruptive nature.
bruh i made an account to reply to this i hope it makes sense
but idk i find it interesting that we quickly recognize slop as inherently negative but generally people don't treat slop applied to real world contexts as harshly
fascinating i agree lena ty
From an online cat researcher's perspective, it is interesting to see that AI-generated cat videos are among the first slop created for maximum engagement. Cats drive engagement. Just to be fair, not all cat videos are slop.
Defining "content" as "preservation of human intentionality" seems, at the very least, highly inaccurate. The bulleted posts you see on LinkedIn, articles about making money, TikToks of attractive people performing a trend - these are content. Meanwhile, personal essays and short stories in lit-fic, and the moving pictures that Martin Scorsese would consider to be "films" - these are NOT content. But they most definitely preserve human intentionality.
you're confusing "content" in the art criticism sense with "content" in the commercial sense (which I have written about before). these are different things entirely
In no. 7 I think "intellectual" can also refer to emotional and nostalgic valences; it's helpful to have your insights here on how to distinguish one's own content from slop. I got a copy of Algospeak BTW but it was shelved in "philosophy" at the large chain bookstore near me, so if fellow readers here are interested in Adam's book, ask a sales clerk to help you find it.
I’m a little confused by the graph: is everything on the graph what is considered slop, or just the dotted line? I wouldn’t think of Starry Night as slop unless it’s there because of its popularity and endless replications that have become cliche (so why that painting and not, say, Mona Lisa?) Was Van Gogh painting for ‘engagement’ as implied here, or the closest to some kind of virality in his time?
"engagement" only matters for social media. This graph is about how "slop" relies on a subjective distinction between form and content. Starry Night has high form, in that it's very successful in its particular medium (being a painting)
taylor swift does not preserve a single drop of human intentionality
I love how this is a catch-22 on slop.
Aleksic's content is tism slop
Yoo fantastic
#2:
Slop is not form. Even the example on offer, "food, not a type of food" illustrates that. "A type of food" indicates a degree of form, distinguishable from other types.
Love that you have Italian brainrot as being more human than Hallmark movies on your chart